LTE: Metro to Loudoun ‘Just Makes Sense’
A reader makes the case for the Silver Line and fears Loudoun could miss its opportunity.
The Metro is at the heart of the Washington, DC, region's success, and we're in danger of missing out on the opportunity to jump on that train (pun intended). It only makes economic sense, both on a personal and countywide scale, that we say, "Yes, we want Metro."
The benefits to individuals are clear: Money saved by riding Metro rather than paying for automobile fuel and maintenance (easily several hundred dollars per month), an easier and more reliable commute, saved time (households in DC region save the equivalent of $705 million in time savings per year thanks to Metro), and wildly increased property values.
As for Loudoun, Metro is our best bet if we ever want to see any real development come to our county. Since the creation of the Metro, over $200 billion has been added in property values within half a mile of Metro stations, the DC region has been able to mitigate the growth of traffic and avoid an additional $11 billion in road infrastructure spending, and the land value near Metro stations generates nearly $3 billion per year in property tax revenue, ten percent of that being directly attributable to Metro.
Those who complain about the cost of investing in rail seem to forget about the greater costs and fewer benefits of the dead-end solution of building more and more roads. If we want to see more congestion, less revenue, and little development, then by all means let's opt out of Metro. But I would like to see Loudoun leverage our position as a prime part of the DC region (with our very own international airport, don't forget) and choose to develop our county into what it is capable of being.
But to do that, we need to connect ourselves with Washington via a public transit system, i.e. the Metro. It just makes sense.
Tyler Holland
Sterling
Loudoun Opt Out
9:11 am on Wednesday, May 30, 2012
Spending $1.5 billion to bring Rail 2 miles past the airport is not the answer to Loudoun's problems. It will necessitate increased taxes, increased traffic, and increased tolls- none of which make Loudoun a desirable place to live or locate a business. Loudoun can Opt Out and Fairfax and MWAA will still build Metrorail to Dulles and possibly Rt. 606 (MWAA has commercial development planned for their land surrounding the station). From the proposed Rt. 772 developments, we can have buses take commuters the 1.9 miles to the Rt. 606 station, or 5.2 miles to the Rt. 28 station. Loudoun's commuter buses are faster, more comfortable, more economical, and more flexible than Rail. Opt Out, pay nothing, and the development will come anyway, if it's economically feasible.
Nancy Ramsay
6:49 pm on Thursday, May 31, 2012
Anything that lengthens my commute - like having first to go to a parking area, then wait for a bus that I hope I can get a seat on and then get from the bus to take the Metro..... How many of these guys making these decisions have to do any of this on a day to day basis?
CH
9:18 am on Wednesday, May 30, 2012
Thank you Tyler for a reasoned approach.
Robert
9:46 am on Wednesday, May 30, 2012
The “just makes sense” argument is an obvious give away to a Pollyanna who doesn’t give much thought to the other side of the story.
The issues raised by opposition to the “deal” are more than noteworthy and give me some feeling that there is leadership here in VA. Sure rail to VA would be nice but at what price to principles, budget flexibility, waste and local autonomy. People opposed to rail are just making sense to the people who have to pay for it.
In the end, let’s hope Loudoun gets an equitable deal.
Melvin Summers
11:08 am on Wednesday, May 30, 2012
Metro does make sense, and Robert, we already paid those taxes. They are sitting in Richmond being distributed by the politicians. Not much of that redistribution of wealth winds up coming back up here to us, the people who drive this state. So excuse me if I think we deserve to tools to do a better job of making our money so they can take some of it and we can support the rest of the states programs.
Yes to Metro
abroderick
11:39 am on Wednesday, May 30, 2012
The Metro will create more jobs and better access to DC. It will get commuters off of hellish roads, and help clear up rush hour traffic into DC. The bus system here is not cutting it. I welcome the metro into Loudoun County.
MEG
11:54 am on Wednesday, May 30, 2012
I, too, think that we would miss an opportunity if we let Metro pass us by. Ask the businesses in Georgetown if they regret not supporting a metro stop (or the residents who have to fight for parking with visitors). The fact of the matter is that business want to locate where there is easy transportation access for their employees and customers. And I don't think it's an either-or option regarding commuter buses. We can certainly have both, as long as there is enough demand (which I think there will be). However, if we change our minds 10 or 20 years down the road, after we see all the business development that is going to Fairfax, it's just going to cost us even more. Certainly, there should be a tight rein on costs, but I think Loudoun would make a big mistake by pulling out of this.
Bob Miller
2:30 pm on Wednesday, May 30, 2012
Those in favor of metro at any expense have not investigated and analyzed the financials associated with joining MWAA. You will have to help pay for the Capitol costs for all of Metro. It has been analyzed by professional not associated with Metro, If Loudoun County Gov't takes on the expenses, your taxes will most likely increase by 1200 per year at a minimum, the tolls will increase for DTR and Greenway, traffic will increase on the free roads. The Lesser study showed that the increase in jobs and economy is minimal with Dulles to Rt 772.
So, if ones mind in exgaged, follow the money and investigate the studies to make an intelligent opinion.
Kadey Mackenzie
2:54 pm on Wednesday, May 30, 2012
It does make sense...excellent letter. YES to metro in Loudoun County!
CC Mojo
3:22 pm on Wednesday, May 30, 2012
It makes perfect sense:
"Since the creation of the Metro, over $200 billion has been added in property values within half a mile of Metro stations, the DC region has been able to mitigate the growth of traffic and avoid an additional $11 billion in road infrastructure spending, and the land value near Metro stations generates nearly $3 billion per year in property tax revenue, ten percent of that being directly attributable to Metro."
Well said, Tyler.
The Baconator
3:28 pm on Wednesday, May 30, 2012
The great majority of us want the metro, look at the polls. The time has come, and it is about time. We need the Metro!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Paul
5:01 pm on Wednesday, May 30, 2012
Opposing metro will not turn Loudoun back into a rural county. Opposing metro will not stop development. We will continue to see traffic grow, we will continue to send our money to richmond, regardless. If we get metro, we get another tool for dealing with some of the results of the growth that is happening.
Commuter buses are a useful tool, not an answer. A fully loaded 8 car metro train carries 1480 passengers. Trains run every 8 minutes at peak. A loudoun county bus can hold 67 passengers. Even with trains not being 100% full at the end of the line, it isn't practical to run enough buses to replace metro. Adding more commuter buses is a great plan, and the subway station is the hub for bus routes. As the sprawl continues to grow over the years, we can only hope that the subway will continue west, and additional lines will develop radiating out from key locations, such as tysons and leesburg. A northbound metro line into maryland would be very nice, and might help to encourage a river crossing in a useful place, somewhere between the beltway and outer nowhere.
Victoria Glenn
9:20 pm on Wednesday, May 30, 2012
Well said Tyler! YES to Metro!!
Melvin Summers
11:34 am on Thursday, May 31, 2012
I agree Paul, stopping metro will not turn Loudoun County back into rolling fields and cow pastures. The people opposed to the Metro do not like change and are stuck in a day that does not exist in this area anymore. Loudoun has grown and grown, but out transportation systems have not. It's time we accept that these changes are permanent and put in good public transportation.
Yes to Metro
abroderick
4:39 pm on Thursday, May 31, 2012
The Metro will get a lot of commuter traffic off of congested roads. In the long run this will reduce carbon emissions. It's the same principal as carpooling. Go green. Go Metro.