.
Feedback

Trio Pushes Conditions, Delay on Metro

Western supervisors offered list of 21 terms for rail agreement.

Loudoun Supervisors Janet Clarke, Ken Reid and Geary Higgins offered a list of 21 terms they believe should be integrated with the county’s decision to participate in the Dulles Corridor Metrorail Project. They offered their list toward the end of a work session Monday on potential ways to finance the project.

The Loudoun Board of Supervisors now has a July 4 deadline to make a decision. A lack of action by that date would commit the county to the project.

Some of the conditions proposed by Clarke (R-Blue Ridge), who is the board’s vice chairman, Reid (R-Leesburg) and Higgins (R-Catoctin) include items that are in progress or require action by another entity, such as giving Virginia two additional seats on the Metropolitan Washington Airport Authority board or calling for a permanent inspector general for that body.

Other board members balked at the notion of making demands that may not be within the control of supervisors or any of the partners in the proposed rail project, the second phase of which would extend the Silver Line now under construction from Wiehle Avenue to Ashburn.

Among the requests is one calling for the state to commit more money and another to oppose project labor agreements, a move previously made.

“I think we need to ask for an extension on the decision on Dulles Rail,” Higgins said Monday. “I cannot vote for this project until we decide tax-wise who’s in and who’s out and who’s going to pay for it.”

But some board members said the 21-point letter should have been presented earlier in the process, not at 4 p.m. the day of one of the last work sessions on rail.

“I got this at 4 o’clock today. This is a wish list,” said Supervisor Matt Letourneau (R-Dulles). “Some of these things are already in the queue. Some of them are things we cannot possibly resolve prior to this vote.”

Supervisors also learned about the preliminary results of a survey that indicated support for rail by a majority of residents in both eastern Loudoun and the rural area. Clarke questioned whether the 1,000-person sample was large enough for accurate results.

Attached is the letter with the 21 terms proposed by the Clarke, Reid and Higgins.

For complete coverage of the Silver Line, go to Patch's Metro Silver Line Project archives.

Sign up for the free daily Ashburn Patch newsletter to stay on top of transportation issues in Loudoun County.

[Correction: Supervisor Letourneau's party affiliation was incorrectly listed in the original version of this story. Patch apologizes for the error.]

Bob Bruhns June 19, 2012 at 07:33 pm
Since 1974 - and they never thought about how to PAY for it until just now, and they never thought about a TAX DISTICT until just now? And where are their plans for the bus connections to this rail line? If the rail line runs day and night, the bus line should too. No? So where are the plans? And what will it cost? And how will you pay for it? Is it factored into the rail decision now?
Since 1974 - and nobody ever thought about running a dedicated bus line where the rail would be going, so that businesses could build up and be ready to benefit from the rail (and pay for it as well)? But of course nobody wants to pay for it, so why should businesses? Except that in Fairfax County, businesses have been paying into a fund for two years now for this Dulles Rail Phase II rail extension, while the irresponsible business and government leaders in Loudoun County were whistling and looking the other way. Your guys were trying to make a killing by dumping it on the county taxpayers, weren't they? tsk tsk And what about the toll paydown, that you better believe will come from Fairfax and Loudoun counties. Is that factored into the rail decision now? And who is going to pay for all of this? (Hint: TAXPAYERS.) Who's kidding who, Victoria? This rail extension is a premature, overpriced, overfinanced, unfunded disaster!
CC Mojo June 19, 2012 at 07:38 pm
This is almost embarrassing... the country is watching and 2 weeks from a vote, suddenly there's a whole new set of seemingly impossible demands? While I can appreciate due diligence to any sort of major vote, it's almost as if there is a question about the ability of Loudoun residents, the majority of Loudoun residents, to know what they want.
Represent the people, BoS, and stop putting off the vote. We are ready for Metro.
Tax Pig June 20, 2012 at 02:37 am
Wow, a group of hard negotiators is forming to let MWAA they are not going to roll all over the people of Loudoun. Great job Team Loudoun!
Congressman Wolf is delinquent in his support payment for Phase 2. I respectfully offer this advice to the Congressman; "You, sir, conceived this Metro puppy, you are the daddy, so instead of passing the buck, pony up or be silent on it, please." http://www.blogger.com/blogger.g?blogID=6313378419940948019#editor/target=post;postID=2960267198848153439
Tax Pig June 20, 2012 at 02:39 am
West Falls Church is up and running. Weihle ave is just a few minutes away.
The real question is are you willing to pay CC girl. This I want a free ride message is getting a bit old.
Tax Pig June 20, 2012 at 02:41 am
Sorry to burst you bubble but here is what Ashburn folks are saying. Not liking it once the who pays gets out of the bag.
Loudoun County Board of Supervisors: Oppose the creation of a Special Metrorail Tax District. http://www.change.org/petitions/loudoun-county-board-of-supervisors-oppose-the-creation-of-a-special-metrorail-tax-district
Tax Pig June 20, 2012 at 02:43 am
If the U.S. Government Can Opt Out, Why Can’t Loudoun?
http://loudounoptout.blogspot.com/2012/06/if-us-government-can-opt-out-why-cant.html
CC Mojo June 20, 2012 at 11:29 am
I'm not the kind of "girl" who doesn't look before she leaps, Pig. You said it yourself, that I know more than most about the issue, and with good reason. So, as for paying up - to quote undoubtedly one of your favorites... you betcha'!
However, I want to point out that you've gone from accusing me of being a landowner, rolling through Countryside in my stretch limo, to making snide comments about me wanting a free ride and/or that I could use my EBT card to pay for my train ride. All of those assumptions are false, yet you persist in trying to negate my opinion by bullying me. You can't even get real with someone you've spoken to in person, yet you think you're some voice of awesome leading the charge against the big, bad train. Pathetic. Why would anyone listen to such a pompous, deceptive, insulting and degrading person? You do more harm than good for your cause, Sir, and people are laughing at you. Laughing. I want Metro even more, just to hear that scream all the way from Pigland. Thanks for the inspiration. XOXO, CC
John June 20, 2012 at 01:10 pm
Tax pig are you harrassing anyone this week that favors the metro? I think your classless for your approach to supervisors who favor or possibily on the fence. Going to Supervisor Volpes church you clearly are the bottom of the barrel. Parking the big piece of junk on supervisors streets where they live and harrassing at home.
Classy guy. I love your wiehle suggestion for loudoun metro users - pay $12-13 dollars to take the greenway and toll road, pay to park( but hope u can find a spot) and them metro in. Clealry someone who isnt affected by crowded roads and trying to get Anywhere during rush hour.
Jason June 20, 2012 at 01:33 pm
Anything that would help releive our crowded roads and ease traffic flow should be considered. We are very close to DC and if there is ever a reason to evacuate many of our loved ones will perish simple bc of the fact we are not willing to find a way to make things better. The existing infrastructure simply cannot ahndle the number of folk that live here- our friends and neighbors. I for one feel terrible that it takes as long as it does to cross Loudoun County to where ever your destination may be (Fairfax, DC, or otherwise) Lets all kick in and work together as AMERICANS to make this work. The need and the demand are there whether you personally agree with it or not.
joe brewer June 20, 2012 at 03:19 pm
Is that a scare tactic Jason? And what a stupid reason to be for metro cc cause the tax pig is against it, that's like Samuel L. Jackson voting for Obama cause he's black. both stupid. Laughing at you and your personal attack of which you claim to be above. Hypocrite is a word you resemble. Wonderful it is that our supervisors want to limit our financial liability, Thanks Mrs. Clarke, Mr. Higgins and Mr. Reid. If you think metro is the correct thing to do why wouldn't the vetting process include our limits and who is going to pay for it? Civic pride was boosted to the 99% level with these supervisors conditions.
Jason June 20, 2012 at 03:50 pm
No scare tactic, it's a reality. There was an accident on the leeburg bi-pass earlier this year that halted movement for half a day. It is scarry that we rely on 7, 15, 50 and 28 to move 300,000 plus comutters each day. Hurricanes and other natural disasters happen often. I hope we never see the day we have to do a large scale evacuation of Loudoun. Just look at a holiday weekend to see how that will go trafficwise. God Bless you and all of us. Let's all get together and find a way to make our county better (like the metro) instead of mocking and insulting one another.
joe brewer June 20, 2012 at 06:01 pm
Honestly I think mockery and insults are more then justified. If the cussing is left out i see no reason for you to impose restrictions on what I write. Are you the self-proclaimed moderator? You and your false prophet feel free to keep your blessings as I think you have very few you can spare .Are you a wolf or a ewe? Howling back at ya!
BCan June 21, 2012 at 03:13 am
Jerry,
I completely agree, urbanization is unavoidable in this case. All of that land is not just going to sit there vacant next to the Greenway. This is the opportunity to give Loudoun County some identity and create some vibrant highrise office and condo developments. Mike, In regards to "not being sampled" for the coming of Metro, I will say that idea of you moving to Ashburn in the first place is a bit ridiculous especially since these Metro stations have been on the planning maps for years and years. I also think it is ironic that there are some people who live in Ashburn that are contesting suburban sprawl when Ashburn, VA is the definition of "Suburban Sprawl". I'm not trying to be rude, but it certainly is interesting to point these things out. If you were trying to avoid the Metro then you definitely should have chosen some other place to live.
BCan June 21, 2012 at 04:17 am
Tax Pig,
I am really curious, where in Loudoun County do you live? Your so called alternative method of commuting (West Falls Church) is not exactly a quick shot to Loudoun. I respect your opinion but I don't think that the alternative to the Metro (doing nothing) is going to be beneficial in the long run. There is already overwhelming support for Metro in Loudoun. I think most people in Loudoun are willing to pay a little bit more in taxes for the Metro because they know that Metro will directly improve their quality of life (in terms of commuting, and access to DC). Obviously the metro extension will cost us money, but the Metro should be seen as an investment. Everyone in Loudoun needs to chip in to get this built now. And yes we are willing to pay for it (well, most of us at least). We can be certain that the price tag will not decrease if we wait.
Jason June 21, 2012 at 03:43 pm
Hey Joe, write as you like. And bless you all the more. I apprecaite you opinion. I just don't understand why every debate has to be so heated. Whether you agree with an item or not, there is no need for all this hotility. Open conversations and freedom to speak your mind are wonderful... but why must it always be so heated? Especially when it comes to anything political, we need to hear all opinions and get the most and best info so that informed decisions can be made. I am even more open to your thoughts if you don't feel the need to insult others to make yours more valid. Is that your motive? I am no prophet, just someone that likes to read about current affairs.
Janie Oldham June 22, 2012 at 07:06 am
Thank goodness we finally have some supervisors looking out for the taxpayers! Who the heck signs a BILLION dollar contract with NO negotiations? It's crazy that our board of supervisors wants to hand over so much of our money without questioning anything. And why is Loudoun county paying for TWO metro stops on federal, airport, property. Let MWAA and WMATA pay for those stops! Why do we have to pay for them?!
Janie Oldham June 22, 2012 at 07:09 am
Jason, I hate to tell you but metro doesn't improve traffic. No metro ever does that. Check out Fairfax county and rt 66 and then tell me that metro helps traffic. More metro means more development which means more cars on the road. duh. Why did you think the developers want metro so bad? More houses! More people! More traffic! Plus, as the toll road prices rise, the county estimates 30,000 more commuters every day on roads in Loudoun. Imagine what a nightmare rt 7 will be with 30,000 more cars a day.
CC Mojo June 22, 2012 at 11:55 am
More development = more revenue = better roads.
Rising tolls = people USING Metro. That's pretty simple math.
Jason June 22, 2012 at 12:42 pm
Janie, I was assuming most of the cars passing on 66 as I ride the Metro were coming from Loudoun or points West since there is no where for them to conveniently get on the Metro. You may be right though however do you really think the builders will build any fewer homes if the Metro does not go through? Unfortunately I think they will build until there is no on left to buy. The builders don't care how we get to and from work. I don't think we should pay for the entire project and I don't have a problem contributing toward the better good. Some of us want it, others rely on it. Hard to believe but some folks don't have cars and only take the Metro.
joe brewer June 22, 2012 at 02:13 pm
I guess we know Jack Potter answer to the extension until December, NO. The only common sense move is to opt out and if they want to extend rail talk to us after we figure out our costs and what we are liable for. Looked at a report from 2002 by the GAO about the MWAA and the same thing the Inspector General said in the interim letter was said back then. No bid contracts, no transparency $200 thousand dollar plus contracts awarded without competition. We'll fix it they said back then same old blah blah blah. Nothing has changed.
Tax Pig June 22, 2012 at 03:10 pm
Ashburn Update Tuesday 6-19: The Tax Pig, Opt Out and David LaRock were chastised and called liars 4:40:10 on Tuesday evening by the Three Blank Check Boys; Buona, Williams, and Letourneau, for informing their constituents that Ashburn and Broadlands are the ground zero of the tax zone. They swore no 2-mile tax zone; it is gone they said. More to the story here:
http://loudounoptout.blogspot.com/2012/06/ashburn-update-tuesday-6-19-tax-pig-opt.html
CC Mojo June 22, 2012 at 03:17 pm
Maybe you should stop lying. That's a good start. Oh, and wasting paper. Nobody believes you, and you've even got the BoS calling you out.
There's nothing like rolling in the mud with pigs. Oink. Oink.
joe brewer June 22, 2012 at 03:45 pm
Sounds like cc knows what it's like to roll in the muck with pigs. During the Board's review of Dulles Rail -- which was allowed under a 2007 agreement with Fairfax County and the Metro Washington Airports Authority (MWAA) we discovered documentation in the projects required Final Environmental Impact Statement (FEIS) showing that the Silver Line to Routes 606 and 772 in Loudoun will not alleviate traffic congestion on our major commuter roads.
I-66, Rt. 50, the Greenway, and the Dulles Toll Road will all remain at service F (Severely congested, gridlock) with or without Phase II! Unfortunately, only a small percentage of Loudoun Commuters are projected to use the Metro for commuting.
Bob Bruhns June 22, 2012 at 03:51 pm
The main benefit will be within 1/4 mile of the rail stations - but because somehow nobody planned for this by installing bus roads where the rail will go, there is almost no business that close to the rail station areas to pay for them. Hence the two-mile tax district idea.
The real problem is that this rail plan is premature. Instead of jumping the gun, why don't you opt out, and see what (if anything) you can arrange in the next 18 months. Of course people will see what happens in Fairfax County, and they won't like it, so you may stay opted out for many years. That would be a good thing, because you can then set up a serious bus transit system instead - and you will need this anyway, to support the rail stations you are contemplating - and extend this bus transit across the county. Then you will have transit routes in place, you will build up business, and in twenty or thirty years, when rail actually becomes appropriate, you can switch it to rail in steps of a few miles at a time - so you can actually afford it. But if you spend everything you have for this rail plan now, how will you pay for the dedicated-road bus system that you will need to support it, and to reserve the future rail routes? You won't... and uncoordinated development will block any future rail extension, while your leaders whistle and look the other way. Big mistake.
Skip Endale June 24, 2012 at 01:42 am
Some of America's largest corporations live in Loudon County. It was the fastest growing county in the United States. It has the highest perhaps 2nd highest per capita income in the United States, year after year. Its backward thinking that prevents Loudon Country from excelling even further, their failure to fund public transportation translates into a daily nightmare for all east-bound residents. Its no coincidence that all three clowns are Republicans...
BCan June 24, 2012 at 03:32 am
Tax Pig,
To be fair, your campaign is quite aggressive and extremely biased. I'm not surprised that they were called liars. After briefly browsing the Loudoun Opt Out website, I have noticed numerous areas where statistics are deliberately misleading to favor your cause. To be completely honest with you, I have not met anyone in Sterling who has opposed the coming of Metro, and yet Loudoun Opt Out goes far out of their way to make it appear like it will destroy Loudoun. And by the way, citing Loudoun Opt Out as a source of information on the Loudoun Opt Out website is NOT VALID... you cannot cite yourself as a source of information. It does not work that way. It is ridiculous things like this that make your campaign appear desperate. It is very obvious to me that a vast majority of the Opt Out Campaign is from Western Loudoun County. Sorry but I don't think that your changing anyone's mind.
Bob Bruhns June 24, 2012 at 07:58 am
Speaking of public transportation, why didn't your leaders demand dedicated-lane bus in the future rail right of way years ago, so that (1) this daily nightmare might have been alleviated much sooner, and (2) business could build up at the future rail stations so that they could pay their fair share when rail became appropriate - because they will be the major beneficiaries of this rail extension.
Go with bus, until rail actually becomes appropriate. You all seem to have 'Train on the Brain', and it seems to be blinding you to the real cost of rail.
joe brewer June 24, 2012 at 10:00 pm
Hopefully a full time Inspector General will be in place in December? The rest of the Inspector General Report comes out in September or Octobe rand the enviroment report comes out in the fall. If the MWAA wants to be heavy handed with a new group of supervisors then show some courage and vote with your mind and opt out.
joe brewer June 24, 2012 at 10:00 pm
Sorry about the spelling!
ACitizen4BetterGovernment June 27, 2012 at 07:47 pm
Time to start a petition to recall Supervisors Janet Clarke, Ken Reid and Geary Higgins.

Newsletter & Alerts

Get the best stories each day and important breaking news

Subscribe

Not from Ashburn Patch? Find your Local Patch »

Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors. Write a new post... What's up? Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell something
Jim June 18, 2013 at 11:22 am
Doug was a coach in Dulles Little League for many years and the entire DLL community sends itsRead More thoughts and prayers to Barbara, Chris and all of Doug's family and friends. Thank you, Payne family, for sharing Doug with us. May he rest in peace.